| | | Shepherd wins toss, will receive. WL defends West goal |
| | | Mike Blewett kickoff 35 yards to the SHEP35, Larry Lowe return 5 yards to the SHEP40 (Josh Beadnell). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep40 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Larry Lowe (Law.Robinson). |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep40 | Tommy Addison rush for 18 yards to the WLU42, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Josh Madrid). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu42 | Tommy Addison rush for 4 yards to the WLU38 (Paul Kallevig;Nick Harding). |
| Shep | 2-6 | at Wlu38 | Tommy Addison rush for 1 yard to the WLU37 (Leo. Redding). |
| Shep | 3-5 | at Wlu37 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Tommy Addison for loss of 3 yards to the WLU40 (Nathan Parry). |
| Shep | 4-8 | at Wlu40 | Matt Martin punt 30 yards to the WLU10, Kyle Rapp return 9 yards to the WLU19 (C. Washington). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 20 yards, TOP 02:34 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu19 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 12:26. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu19 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kashif Walls for 61 yards to the SHEP20, 1ST DOWN WLU (Layton Hersh). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep20 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 14 yards to the SHEP6, 1ST DOWN WLU (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 1-G | at Shep06 | Kevon Calhoun rush for no gain to the SHEP6 (Brian Taylor). |
| Wlu | 2-G | at Shep06 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete. |
| Wlu | 3-G | at Shep06 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Kashif Walls. |
| Wlu | 4-G | at Shep06 | Mike Blewett field goal attempt from 23 GOOD, clock 10:43. |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 3, Shepherd University 0 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 75 yards, TOP 01:43 |
| | | Mike Blewett kickoff 33 yards to the SHEP37, Larry Lowe return 12 yards to the SHEP49 (Lamarr Stewart;Jeremy Presley). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep49 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 10:38. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep49 | Kevin Clancy sacked for loss of 6 yards to the SHEP43 (Joey McGee). |
| Shep | 2-16 | at Shep43 | Tommy Addison rush for 1 yard to the SHEP44 (Joey McGee). |
| Shep | 3-15 | at Shep44 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Neal Hardie (Mike Kane). |
| Shep | 4-15 | at Shep44 | Matt Martin punt 47 yards to the WLU9, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 5 yards, TOP 01:41 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu09 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 08:57. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu09 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 1 yard to the WLU10 (Will Wheeler). |
| Wlu | 2-9 | at Wlu10 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 21 yards to the WLU31, 1ST DOWN WLU (Ben Minturn). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu31 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for no gain to the WLU31 (T.J. Taylor;Jon Schwartz). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu31 | PENALTY SHEP offside (Ryan Peacock) 6 yards to the WLU37. |
| Wlu | 2-4 | at Wlu37 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 16 yards to the SHEP47, 1ST DOWN WLU. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep47 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kashif Walls for 6 yards to the SHEP41 (Brian Taylor). |
| Wlu | 2-4 | at Shep41 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 3 yards to the SHEP38 (Frank Herrera). |
| Wlu | 3-1 | at Shep38 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Eddie Hills. |
| Wlu | 4-1 | at Shep38 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Willie Walker. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 53 yards, TOP 03:25 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep38 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 05:32. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep38 | Nate Hoyte rush for 6 yards to the SHEP44 (Nick Harding). |
| Shep | 2-4 | at Shep44 | Nate Hoyte rush for 9 yards to the WLU47, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Dante D'Antonio). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu47 | Nate Hoyte rush for loss of 2 yards to the WLU49 (Jayson Keyser). |
| Shep | 2-12 | at Wlu49 | Nate Hoyte rush for 11 yards to the WLU38 (Jayson Keyser). |
| Shep | 3-1 | at Wlu38 | Nate Hoyte rush for no gain to the WLU38 (Joey McGee). |
| Shep | 4-1 | at Wlu38 | Kevin Clancy rush for loss of 2 yards to the WLU40 (Joey McGee). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 22 yards, TOP 03:10 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu40 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 02:22. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu40 | PENALTY WLU IB (Kashif Walls) 10 yards to the WLU30. |
| Wlu | 1-20 | at Wlu30 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete. |
| Wlu | 2-20 | at Wlu30 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Eddie Hills for 23 yards to the SHEP47, 1ST DOWN WLU (Deante Steele). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep47 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 8 yards to the SHEP39 (Jon Schwartz). |
| Wlu | 2-2 | at Shep39 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 1 yard to the SHEP38 (Brian Taylor;Jon Schwartz). |
| Wlu | 3-1 | at Shep38 | Zach Amedro rush for no gain to the SHEP38 (T.J. Taylor). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 22 yards, TOP 02:30 |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 3, Shepherd University 0 |
| Wlu | 4-1 | at Shep38 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wlu | 4-1 | at Shep38 | Kevon Calhoun rush for loss of 2 yards to the SHEP40 (Elijah Davis;Ben Minturn). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 20 yards, TOP 02:30 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep40 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 14:52. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep40 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Neal Hardie for 37 yards to the WLU23, 1ST DOWN SHEP. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu23 | Tommy Addison rush for 2 yards to the WLU21 (Paul Kallevig). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Wlu21 | PENALTY SHEP false start 5 yards to the WLU26. |
| Shep | 2-13 | at Wlu26 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Nasser Muhammad for 26 yards to the WLU0, 1ST DOWN SHEP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 13:23. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 7, West Liberty Univ. 3 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 60 yards, TOP 01:29 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 65 yards to the WLU5, Eddie Hills return 11 yards to the WLU16 (Tommy Whalen). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu16 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 13:15. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu16 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 11 yards to the WLU27, 1ST DOWN WLU (Deante Steele). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu27 | Zach Amedro pass intercepted by Layton Hersh at the SHEP48, Layton Hersh return 0 yards to the SHEP48. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 11 yards, TOP 00:31 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep48 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 12:44. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep48 | Tommy Addison rush for no gain to the SHEP48 (Matt Betz). |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep48 | Tommy Addison rush for 5 yards to the WLU47 (Isaac Omaits). |
| Shep | 3-5 | at Wlu47 | Nasser Muhammad rush for 1 yard to the WLU46 (Dante D'Antonio). |
| Shep | 4-4 | at Wlu46 | Matt Martin punt 36 yards to the WLU10, Kyle Rapp return 6 yards to the WLU16, PENALTY WLU IB 8 yards to the WLU8, 1st and 10, WLU ball on WLU8. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:59 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu08 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 10:45. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu08 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 1 yard to the WLU9 (Chris Patton;Ryan Peacock). |
| Wlu | 2-9 | at Wlu09 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Ryan Travis (T.J. Taylor). |
| Wlu | 3-9 | at Wlu09 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Kashif Walls. |
| Wlu | 4-9 | at Wlu09 | Mike Blewett punt 36 yards to the WLU45, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 1 yards, TOP 00:53 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu45 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 09:52. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu45 | Nate Hoyte rush for 4 yards to the WLU41 (Joey McGee). |
| Shep | 2-6 | at Wlu41 | Nate Hoyte rush for 9 yards to the WLU32, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Nick Harding). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu32 | Nate Hoyte rush for 3 yards to the WLU29 (Joey McGee). |
| Shep | 2-7 | at Wlu29 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Geoff Fry for loss of 4 yards to the WLU33 (Nick Harding). |
| Shep | 3-11 | at Wlu33 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Larry Lowe. |
| Shep | 4-11 | at Wlu33 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Neal Hardie for 33 yards to the WLU0, 1ST DOWN SHEP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:25. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 14, West Liberty Univ. 3 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 45 yards, TOP 02:27 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 62 yards to the WLU8, Kashif Walls return 15 yards to the WLU23 (Maurice Perry). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu23 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 07:18. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu23 | Zach Amedro sacked for loss of 8 yards to the WLU15 (Will Wheeler;T.J. Taylor). |
| Wlu | 2-18 | at Wlu15 | PENALTY WLU false start (Willie Walker) 5 yards to the WLU10. |
| Wlu | 2-23 | at Wlu10 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kashif Walls for loss of 1 yard to the WLU9 (Brian Taylor). |
| Wlu | 3-24 | at Wlu09 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Eddie Hills. |
| Wlu | 4-24 | at Wlu09 | Mike Blewett rush for loss of 9 yards to the WLU0, out-of-bounds, TEAM safety, clock 05:19. |
| | | Shepherd University 16, West Liberty Univ. 3 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, minus 23 yards, TOP 01:59 |
| | | Mike Blewett kickoff 41 yards to the SHEP39, Deante Steele return 31 yards to the WLU30 (Raphael Johnson). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu30 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 05:04. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu30 | Tommy Addison rush for no gain to the WLU30 (Jayson Keyser). |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Wlu30 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Larry Lowe. |
| Shep | 3-10 | at Wlu30 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Neal Hardie. |
| Shep | 4-10 | at Wlu30 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:55 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu30 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 04:09. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu30 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Eddie Hills for 12 yards to the WLU42, 1ST DOWN WLU (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu42 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 5 yards to the WLU47 (Brian Taylor;Ricky Congo). |
| Wlu | 2-5 | at Wlu47 | PENALTY WLU false start (Eddie Hills) 5 yards to the WLU42. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu42 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kashif Walls for 14 yards to the SHEP44, 1ST DOWN WLU (Deante Steele). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep44 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Kevon Calhoun. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep44 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Kashif Walls. |
| Wlu | 3-10 | at Shep44 | Zach Amedro rush for 13 yards to the SHEP31, 1ST DOWN WLU (Will Wheeler). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep31 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Kevon Calhoun. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep31 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 8 yards to the SHEP23 (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 3-2 | at Shep23 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 23 yards to the SHEP0, 1ST DOWN WLU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:10. |
| | | Mike Blewett kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 16, West Liberty Univ. 10 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 70 yards, TOP 02:59 |
| | | Mike Blewett kickoff 38 yards to the SHEP32, C. Washington return 14 yards to the SHEP46 (Nic Lauer). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep46 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 01:05. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep46 | Tommy Addison rush for 8 yards to the WLU46 (Mike Buffo). |
| Shep | 2-2 | at Wlu46 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Nasser Muhammad for 1 yard to the WLU45 (Mike Kane). |
| Shep | 3-1 | at Wlu45 | Timeout Shepherd University, clock 00:35. |
| Shep | 3-1 | at Wlu45 | Tommy Addison rush for no gain to the WLU45 (Matt Betz). |
| Shep | 4-1 | at Wlu45 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Tommy Addison. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 9 yards, TOP 00:54 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu45 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 00:11. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu45 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 19 yards to the SHEP36, 1ST DOWN WLU (Ben Minturn). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep36 | Timeout West Liberty Univ., clock 00:01. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep36 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete (Deante Steele). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep36 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 19 yards, TOP 00:11 |
| | | Shepherd University 16, West Liberty Univ. 10 |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep36 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, SHEP ball on SHEP30. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 19 yards, TOP 00:11 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 55 yards to the WLU15, Dontrell Lee return 8 yards to the WLU23 (Maurice Perry). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu23 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 14:53. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu23 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu23 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 10 yards to the WLU33, 1ST DOWN WLU (Deante Steele). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu33 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 8 yards to the WLU41 (Elijah Davis;Will Wheeler). |
| Wlu | 3-2 | at Wlu41 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Kashif Walls (Deante Steele). |
| Wlu | 4-2 | at Wlu41 | Mike Blewett punt 31 yards to the SHEP28, Deante Steele return 1 yards to the SHEP29 (Fred Kimbro). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 18 yards, TOP 01:39 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep29 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 13:14. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep29 | Tommy Addison rush for 2 yards to the SHEP31 (Nick Harding). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Shep31 | Tommy Addison rush for 2 yards to the SHEP33 (Isaac Omaits). |
| Shep | 3-6 | at Shep33 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Larry Lowe for 13 yards to the SHEP46, 1ST DOWN SHEP. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep46 | Tommy Addison rush for 2 yards to the SHEP48 (Matt Betz;Joey McGee). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Shep48 | Tommy Addison rush for 1 yard to the SHEP49 (Joey McGee), PENALTY WLU personal foul (Joey McGee) 15 yards to the WLU36, 1ST DOWN SHEP. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu36 | 1st and 10. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu36 | Tommy Addison rush for 5 yards to the WLU31 (Clay Beeler). |
| Shep | 2-5 | at Wlu31 | Tommy Addison rush for 1 yard to the WLU30 (Matt Betz). |
| Shep | 3-4 | at Wlu30 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Neal Hardie for 26 yards to the WLU4, 1ST DOWN SHEP, out-of-bounds. |
| Shep | 1-G | at Wlu04 | Tommy Addison rush for 4 yards to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 08:58. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 23, West Liberty Univ. 10 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 71 yards, TOP 04:16 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 63 yards to the WLU7, Adam Hill return 20 yards to the WLU27 (David White). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu27 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 08:50. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu27 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 2 yards to the WLU29 (Chris Patton). |
| Wlu | 2-8 | at Wlu29 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 3 yards to the WLU32 (Ben Minturn). |
| Wlu | 3-5 | at Wlu32 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete (Layton Hersh). |
| Wlu | 4-5 | at Wlu32 | Mike Blewett punt 44 yards to the SHEP24, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:44 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep24 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 07:06. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep24 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Larry Lowe for 10 yards to the SHEP34, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Nick Harding). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep34 | PENALTY SHEP holding (Geoff Fry) 10 yards to the SHEP24. |
| Shep | 1-20 | at Shep24 | Nate Hoyte rush for 5 yards to the SHEP29 (Clay Beeler). |
| Shep | 2-15 | at Shep29 | Nate Hoyte rush for 2 yards to the SHEP31 (Joey McGee). |
| Shep | 3-13 | at Shep31 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Pat McClain. |
| Shep | 4-13 | at Shep31 | Matt Martin punt 34 yards to the WLU35, downed. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 7 yards, TOP 02:25 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu35 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 04:41. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu35 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kashif Walls for 18 yards to the SHEP47, 1ST DOWN WLU (Deante Steele). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep47 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kashif Walls for 14 yards to the SHEP33, 1ST DOWN WLU (Deante Steele). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep33 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 8 yards to the SHEP25. |
| Wlu | 2-2 | at Shep25 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Willie Walker. |
| Wlu | 3-2 | at Shep25 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 25 yards to the SHEP0, 1ST DOWN WLU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:04. |
| | | Mike Blewett kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 23, West Liberty Univ. 17 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 65 yards, TOP 01:55 |
| | | Mike Blewett kickoff 56 yards to the SHEP14, Deante Steele return 86 yards to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:46. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 30, West Liberty Univ. 17 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 64 yards to the WLU6, Adam Hill return 23 yards to the WLU29 (C. Washington). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu29 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 02:39. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu29 | Eddie Hills rush for loss of 1 yard to the WLU28 (Jon Heavner;Jon Schwartz). |
| Wlu | 2-11 | at Wlu28 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Willie Walker (Pat Blackmon). |
| Wlu | 3-11 | at Wlu28 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 22 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN WLU (Ben Minturn). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu50 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 3 yards to the SHEP47 (Chris Patton). |
| Wlu | 2-7 | at Shep47 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete (T.J. Taylor). |
| Wlu | 3-7 | at Shep47 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 12 yards to the SHEP35, 1ST DOWN WLU (Deante Steele). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep35 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 3 yards to the SHEP32 (T.J. Taylor;Maurice Perry). |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 39 yards, TOP 02:58 |
| | | Shepherd University 30, West Liberty Univ. 17 |
| Wlu | 2-7 | at Shep32 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wlu | 2-7 | at Shep32 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete. |
| Wlu | 3-7 | at Shep32 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kashif Walls for 32 yards to the SHEP0, 1ST DOWN WLU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 14:41. |
| | | Mike Blewett kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd University 30, West Liberty Univ. 24 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 71 yards, TOP 02:58 |
| | | Mike Blewett kickoff 22 yards to the SHEP48, downed, PENALTY WLU illegal kicking 6 yards to the WLU46, 1st and 10, SHEP ball on SHEP46. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep46 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 14:31. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep46 | Tommy Addison rush for 41 yards to the WLU13, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Derrick Evans), PENALTY SHEP personal foul (Bobby Humphries) 15 yards to the WLU28. |
| Shep | 1-25 | at Wlu28 | 1st and 10. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | Tommy Addison rush for no gain to the WLU28 (Clay Beeler). |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Wlu28 | Tommy Addison rush for no gain to the WLU28. |
| Shep | 3-10 | at Wlu28 | Kevin Clancy pass intercepted by Derrick Evans at the WLU17, Derrick Evans return 0 yards to the WLU17. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 26 yards, TOP 01:35 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu17 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 12:56. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu17 | Eddie Hills rush for 7 yards to the WLU24 (Will Wheeler). |
| Wlu | 2-3 | at Wlu24 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 9 yards to the WLU33, 1ST DOWN WLU (Deante Steele). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Eddie Hills for 5 yards to the WLU38 (Layton Hersh). |
| Wlu | 2-5 | at Wlu38 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 5 yards to the WLU43, 1ST DOWN WLU (Ben Minturn). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu43 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kashif Walls for 42 yards to the SHEP15, 1ST DOWN WLU (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep15 | Kevon Calhoun rush for no gain to the SHEP15 (Jon Schwartz). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep15 | Zach Amedro sacked for loss of 8 yards to the SHEP23 (Brian Taylor). |
| Wlu | 3-18 | at Shep23 | Zach Amedro pass intercepted by Layton Hersh at the SHEP5, Layton Hersh return 4 yards to the SHEP9 (Eddie Hills). |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 60 yards, TOP 04:07 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep09 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 08:49. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep09 | Tommy Addison rush for 2 yards to the SHEP11 (Matt Betz). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Shep11 | Tommy Addison rush for 2 yards to the SHEP13 (Matt Betz). |
| Shep | 3-6 | at Shep13 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Neal Hardie. |
| Shep | 4-6 | at Shep13 | Matt Martin punt 16 yards to the SHEP29, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 01:33 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep29 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 07:16. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep29 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Kevon Calhoun. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep29 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 6 yards to the SHEP23 (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 3-4 | at Shep23 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kashif Walls for 18 yards to the SHEP5, 1ST DOWN WLU (Deante Steele). |
| Wlu | 1-G | at Shep05 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Kashif Walls (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 2-G | at Shep05 | Kevon Calhoun rush for loss of 1 yard to the SHEP6 (T.J. Taylor). |
| Wlu | 3-G | at Shep06 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 6 yards to the SHEP0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 05:14. |
| | | Mike Blewett kick attempt good. |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 31, Shepherd University 30 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 29 yards, TOP 02:02 |
| | | Mike Blewett kickoff 32 yards to the SHEP38, C. Washington return 7 yards to the SHEP45 (Fred Kimbro). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep45 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 05:08. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep45 | Tommy Addison rush for 6 yards to the WLU49 (Joey McGee). |
| Shep | 2-4 | at Wlu49 | Kevin Clancy rush for loss of 3 yards to the SHEP48 (Nick Harding). |
| Shep | 3-7 | at Shep48 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Larry Lowe. |
| Shep | 4-7 | at Shep48 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Neal Hardie. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 3 yards, TOP 01:16 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep48 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 03:52. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep48 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 13 yards to the SHEP35, 1ST DOWN WLU (Layton Hersh). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep35 | PENALTY WLU false start (Eddie Hills) 5 yards to the SHEP40. |
| Wlu | 1-15 | at Shep40 | Timeout Shepherd University, clock 03:16. |
| Wlu | 1-15 | at Shep40 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 7 yards to the SHEP33 (Layton Hersh). |
| Wlu | 2-8 | at Shep33 | Timeout Shepherd University, clock 03:02. |
| Wlu | 2-8 | at Shep33 | Ryan Travis rush for no gain to the SHEP33 (Ben Minturn). |
| Wlu | 3-8 | at Shep33 | Timeout Shepherd University, clock 02:58. |
| Wlu | 3-8 | at Shep33 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Kashif Walls. |
| Wlu | 4-8 | at Shep33 | Mike Blewett punt 18 yards to the SHEP15, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 15 yards, TOP 01:04 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep15 | SHEPHERD UNIVERSITY drive start at 02:48. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep15 | Tommy Addison rush for 4 yards to the SHEP19 (Clay Beeler). |
| Shep | 2-6 | at Shep19 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Nasser Muhammad for 8 yards to the SHEP27, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Law.Robinson;Clay Beeler). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep27 | TEAM pass incomplete. |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep27 | PENALTY SHEP false start (Geoff Fry) 5 yards to the SHEP22. |
| Shep | 2-15 | at Shep22 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Neal Hardie for 22 yards to the SHEP44, 1ST DOWN SHEP. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep44 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Pat McClain. |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep44 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Nasser Muhammad for 12 yards to the WLU44, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Law.Robinson). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu44 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete. |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Wlu44 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Pat McClain. |
| Shep | 3-10 | at Wlu44 | Kevin Clancy pass intercepted by Clay Beeler at the WLU35, Clay Beeler return 1 yards to the WLU36. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 41 yards, TOP 01:08 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu36 | WEST LIBERTY UNIV. drive start at 01:40. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu36 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the WLU35. |
| Wlu | 2-11 | at Wlu35 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the WLU34. |
| Wlu | 3-12 | at Wlu34 | TEAM rush for loss of 1 yard to the WLU33. |
| Wlu | 4-13 | at Wlu33 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, minus 3 yards, TOP 01:40 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | West Liberty Univ. 31, Shepherd University 30 |