| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep30 | Change of possession, WLU ball on WLU30, 1st and 10. |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 38 yards to the SHEP32, Dom Jones return 0 yards to the SHEP32, out-of-bounds. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep32 | SHEPHERD drive start at 14:58. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep32 | Tommy Addison rush for no gain to the SHEP32 (Jayson Keyser). |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep32 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Robert Byrd for 9 yards to the SHEP41. |
| Shep | 3-1 | at Shep41 | Tommy Addison rush for 3 yards to the SHEP44, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Mike Buffo). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep44 | Tommy Addison rush for 2 yards to the SHEP46 (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Shep46 | PENALTY SHEP delay of game (Kevin Clancy) 5 yards to the SHEP41. |
| Shep | 2-13 | at Shep41 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Nik Norrell for 7 yards to the SHEP48 (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 3-6 | at Shep48 | Kevin Clancy sacked for loss of 6 yards to the SHEP42, fumble by Kevin Clancy recovered by SHEP Kevin Clancy at SHEP44. |
| Shep | 4-10 | at Shep44 | Eric Dobratz punt 23 yards to the WLU33, downed. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 12 yards, TOP 03:52 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 11:06. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Brandon Carver for 5 yards to the WLU38 (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 2-5 | at Wlu38 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 4 yards to the WLU42 (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 3-1 | at Wlu42 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Ryan Travis (Brian Taylor). |
| Wlu | 4-1 | at Wlu42 | Mike Blewett punt 40 yards to the SHEP18, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:11 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep18 | SHEPHERD drive start at 09:55. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep18 | Nate Hoyte rush for 3 yards to the SHEP21 (Fred Kimbro). |
| Shep | 2-7 | at Shep21 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Neal Hardie for 51 yards to the WLU28, 1ST DOWN SHEP, out-of-bounds (Deron Taylor). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Scot Riddell for 5 yards to the WLU23 (Jayson Keyser). |
| Shep | 2-5 | at Wlu23 | Nate Hoyte rush for 2 yards to the WLU21 (Ryan Mirich). |
| Shep | 3-3 | at Wlu21 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Robert Byrd. |
| Shep | 4-3 | at Wlu21 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Neal Hardie, PENALTY WLU holding (Carl Hayles) 10 yards to the WLU11, 1ST DOWN SHEP, NO PLAY. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu11 | SHEP ball on WLU11. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu11 | Nate Hoyte rush for 11 yards to the WLU0, 1ST DOWN SHEP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 07:19. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd 7, West Liberty U 0 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 82 yards, TOP 02:36 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 55 yards to the WLU15, out-of-bounds, WLU ball on WLU40. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu40 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 07:19. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu40 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 6 yards to the WLU46 (Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 2-4 | at Wlu46 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 15 yards to the SHEP39, 1ST DOWN WLU (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep39 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Brandon Carver. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep39 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Jermaine Carter, PENALTY SHEP offside declined, PENALTY SHEP personal foul (Will Wheeler) 15 yards to the SHEP24, 1ST DOWN WLU, NO PLAY. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep24 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 3 yards to the SHEP21 (Xavier Tyler), PENALTY WLU holding (Nick Madia) 10 yards to the SHEP34, NO PLAY. |
| Wlu | 1-20 | at Shep34 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Ryan Travis. |
| Wlu | 2-20 | at Shep34 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 5 yards to the SHEP29 (Will Wheeler). |
| Wlu | 3-15 | at Shep29 | PENALTY SHEP offside (Mike Franklin) 5 yards to the SHEP24. |
| Wlu | 3-10 | at Shep24 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 16 yards to the SHEP8, 1ST DOWN WLU, out-of-bounds (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 1-G | at Shep08 | Kevon Calhoun rush for loss of 2 yards to the SHEP10 (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 2-G | at Shep10 | Zach Amedro rush for 10 yards to the SHEP0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:38. |
| | | Mike Blewett kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd 7, West Liberty U 7 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 60 yards, TOP 03:43 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 50 yards to the SHEP20, Justin Ford return 0 yards to the SHEP20. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep20 | SHEPHERD drive start at 03:36. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep20 | Tommy Addison rush for 3 yards to the SHEP23 (Clay Beeler). |
| Shep | 2-7 | at Shep23 | Robert Byrd rush for 2 yards to the SHEP25 (Alec Wood). |
| Shep | 3-5 | at Shep25 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Scot Riddell. |
| Shep | 4-5 | at Shep25 | Eric Dobratz punt 31 yards to the WLU44, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:27 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu44 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 02:09. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu44 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 12 yards to the SHEP44, 1ST DOWN WLU (Cor. Washington). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep44 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Pauly Ferguson for 8 yards to the SHEP36, out-of-bounds (Chris Patton). |
| Wlu | 2-2 | at Shep36 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 8 yards to the SHEP28, 1ST DOWN WLU (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep28 | Zach Amedro rush for 12 yards to the SHEP16, out-of-bounds (Cor. Washington), PENALTY WLU holding (Ryan Scaperotta) 10 yards to the SHEP38, NO PLAY. |
| Wlu | 1-20 | at Shep38 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Ryan Travis (Brian Taylor). |
| Wlu | 2-20 | at Shep38 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Ryan Travis (Cor. Washington). |
| Wlu | 3-20 | at Shep38 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 17 yards to the SHEP21. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 35 yards, TOP 04:58 |
| | | Shepherd 7, West Liberty U 7 |
| Wlu | 4-3 | at Shep21 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wlu | 4-3 | at Shep21 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 10 yards to the SHEP11, 1ST DOWN WLU, out-of-bounds. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep11 | Ryan Travis rush for loss of 4 yards to the SHEP15 (Howard Jones). |
| Wlu | 2-14 | at Shep15 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete (Xavier Tyler). |
| Wlu | 3-14 | at Shep15 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Brandon Carver (Keon Robinson), PENALTY SHEP personal foul 8 yards to the SHEP7, 1ST DOWN WLU, NO PLAY. |
| Wlu | 1-G | at Shep07 | DeVaughn Gordon rush for 3 yards to the SHEP4 (Ben Minturn). |
| Wlu | 2-G | at Shep04 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 2 yards to the SHEP2 (Brian Taylor). |
| Wlu | 3-G | at Shep02 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 2 yards to the SHEP0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:18. |
| | | Mike Blewett kick attempt good. |
| | | West Liberty U 14, Shepherd 7 |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 56 yards, TOP 04:58 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 23 yards to the SHEP47, Bobby Humphries return -3 yards to the SHEP44 (TJ Lesniewski). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep44 | SHEPHERD drive start at 12:11. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep44 | Kevin Clancy rush for 6 yards to the 50 yardline (Clay Beeler). |
| Shep | 2-4 | at Shep50 | Tommy Addison rush for 10 yards to the WLU40 (Fred Kimbro), PENALTY SHEP holding (Dom Jones) 10 yards to the 50 yardline. |
| Shep | 2-4 | at Shep50 | 2nd and 4. |
| Shep | 2-4 | at Shep50 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Larry Lowe for 3 yards to the WLU47 (Law. Robinson). |
| Shep | 3-1 | at Wlu47 | Tommy Addison rush for 3 yards to the WLU44, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Fred Kimbro). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu44 | Justin Ford rush for loss of 1 yard to the WLU45 (Deron Taylor), PENALTY SHEP holding (Steven Jackson) 10 yards to the SHEP46, NO PLAY. |
| Shep | 1-20 | at Shep46 | Timeout Shepherd, clock 09:27. |
| Shep | 1-20 | at Shep46 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Larry Lowe for 26 yards to the WLU28, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Alec Wood). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Nik Norrell. |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Wlu28 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Nik Norrell (Alec Wood). |
| Shep | 3-10 | at Wlu28 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Pat McClain. |
| Shep | 4-10 | at Wlu28 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Robert Byrd. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 28 yards, TOP 03:33 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 08:38. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu28 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 28 yards to the SHEP44, 1ST DOWN WLU (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep44 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 11 yards to the SHEP33, 1ST DOWN WLU (Brian Taylor). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep33 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 13 yards to the SHEP20, 1ST DOWN WLU (Chris Patton). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep20 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 6 yards to the SHEP14 (Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 2-4 | at Shep14 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 14 yards to the SHEP0, 1ST DOWN WLU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 06:48. |
| | | Mike Blewett kick attempt good. |
| | | West Liberty U 21, Shepherd 7 |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 72 yards, TOP 01:50 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 40 yards to the SHEP30, Keon Robinson return 10 yards to the SHEP40, fumble by Keon Robinson recovered by WLU C. Pitsenberger at SHEP41. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep41 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 06:36. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep41 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for no gain to the SHEP41 (Cor. Washington). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep41 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Pauly Ferguson. |
| Wlu | 3-10 | at Shep41 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 6 yards to the SHEP35, out-of-bounds (Will Wheeler). |
| Wlu | 4-4 | at Shep35 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 10 yards to the SHEP25, 1ST DOWN WLU, out-of-bounds. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep25 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 6 yards to the SHEP19 (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 2-4 | at Shep19 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 9 yards to the SHEP10, 1ST DOWN WLU (Chris Patton). |
| Wlu | 1-G | at Shep10 | DeVaughn Gordon rush for 3 yards to the SHEP7 (Brian Taylor). |
| Wlu | 2-G | at Shep07 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 7 yards to the SHEP0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:28. |
| | | Mike Blewett kick attempt good. |
| | | West Liberty U 28, Shepherd 7 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 41 yards, TOP 03:16 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 35 yards to the SHEP35, Larry Lowe return 10 yards to the SHEP45 (Jayson Keyser). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep45 | SHEPHERD drive start at 03:20. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep45 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Neal Hardie for 39 yards to the WLU16, 1ST DOWN SHEP. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu16 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Neal Hardie. |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Wlu16 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Dom Jones. |
| Shep | 3-10 | at Wlu16 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Dom Jones for 13 yards to the WLU3, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Alec Wood;Clay Beeler). |
| Shep | 1-G | at Wlu03 | Timeout Shepherd, clock 02:29. |
| Shep | 1-G | at Wlu03 | Jimmy Sutch rush for 2 yards to the WLU1 (Matt Betz). |
| Shep | 2-G | at Wlu01 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Dom Jones for 1 yard to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 02:05. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt failed (fumbled). |
| | | West Liberty U 28, Shepherd 13 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 55 yards, TOP 01:15 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 70 yards to the WLU0, touchback. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 02:05. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 9 yards to the WLU29, out-of-bounds (Chris Patton). |
| Wlu | 2-1 | at Wlu29 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 4 yards to the WLU33 (Keon Robinson), PENALTY WLU illegal motion (Kevon Calhoun) 5 yards to the WLU24, NO PLAY. |
| Wlu | 2-6 | at Wlu24 | Zach Amedro sacked for loss of 6 yards to the WLU18 (Will Wheeler). |
| Wlu | 3-12 | at Wlu18 | Timeout West Liberty U, clock 01:28. |
| Wlu | 3-12 | at Wlu18 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 6 yards to the WLU24 (Cor. Washington). |
| Wlu | 4-6 | at Wlu24 | Timeout Shepherd, clock 01:23. |
| Wlu | 4-6 | at Wlu24 | Mike Blewett punt 9 yards to the WLU33, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 00:49 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | SHEPHERD drive start at 01:16. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Nik Norrell (Carl Hayles), PENALTY WLU pass interference (Carl Hayles) 16 yards to the WLU17, 1ST DOWN SHEP, NO PLAY. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu17 | Kevin Clancy pass intercepted by Carl Hayles at the WLU8, Carl Hayles return 13 yards to the WLU21 (Jimmy Sutch). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 16 yards, TOP 00:15 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu21 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 01:01. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu21 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 6 yards to the WLU27 (Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 2-4 | at Wlu27 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Jermaine Carter. |
| Wlu | 3-4 | at Wlu27 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 9 yards to the WLU36, 1ST DOWN WLU (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu36 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 15 yards, TOP 01:01 |
| | | West Liberty U 28, Shepherd 13 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu36 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu36 | SHEP ball on SHEP30. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 01:01 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 68 yards to the WLU2, DeVaughn Gordon return 16 yards to the WLU18 (Charles Scott). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu18 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 14:54. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu18 | Kevon Calhoun rush for loss of 3 yards to the WLU15 (Will Wheeler). |
| Wlu | 2-13 | at Wlu15 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Pauly Ferguson. |
| Wlu | 3-13 | at Wlu15 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 16 yards to the WLU31, 1ST DOWN WLU (Chris Patton), PENALTY SHEP offside declined. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu31 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 4 yards to the WLU35 (Xavier Tyler). |
| Wlu | 2-6 | at Wlu35 | PENALTY WLU personal foul (Ryan Travis) 15 yards to the WLU20. |
| Wlu | 2-21 | at Wlu20 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 16 yards to the WLU36 (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 3-5 | at Wlu36 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 11 yards to the WLU47, 1ST DOWN WLU (Ben Minturn). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu47 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 2 yards to the WLU49 (Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 2-8 | at Wlu49 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Kevon Calhoun. |
| Wlu | 3-8 | at Wlu49 | Zach Amedro rush for 10 yards to the SHEP41, 1ST DOWN WLU (Cor. Washington). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep41 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 4 yards to the SHEP37 (Jon Heavner). |
| Wlu | 2-6 | at Shep37 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 13 yards to the SHEP24, 1ST DOWN WLU (Dominique Dixon). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep24 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 24 yards to the SHEP0, 1ST DOWN WLU, TOUCHDOWN, clock 10:28. |
| Wlu | 1-G | at Shep03 | PENALTY WLU false start (Matt Betz) 5 yards to the SHEP8. |
| | | Mike Blewett kick attempt good. |
| | | West Liberty U 35, Shepherd 13 |
| | | Drive: 12 plays, 82 yards, TOP 04:33 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 35 yards to the SHEP35, Larry Lowe return 11 yards to the SHEP46 (TJ Lesniewski). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep46 | SHEPHERD drive start at 10:21. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep46 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Robert Byrd (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep46 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Nik Norrell for 39 yards to the WLU15, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Deron Taylor). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu15 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Dom Jones for 15 yards to the WLU0, 1ST DOWN SHEP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:45. |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | West Liberty U 35, Shepherd 20 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 54 yards, TOP 00:39 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 70 yards to the WLU0, touchback. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 09:42. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Willie Walker. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu20 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 5 yards to the WLU25 (Ben Minturn). |
| Wlu | 3-5 | at Wlu25 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 8 yards to the WLU33, 1ST DOWN WLU (Ben Minturn). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 3 yards to the WLU36 (Will Wheeler), PENALTY WLU holding (Ryan Scaperotta) 12 yards to the WLU24. |
| Wlu | 1-19 | at Wlu24 | 1st and 19. |
| Wlu | 1-19 | at Wlu24 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Brandon Carver for 43 yards to the SHEP33, 1ST DOWN WLU, PENALTY SHEP personal foul 15 yards to the SHEP18, 1ST DOWN WLU. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep18 | 1st and 10. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep18 | PENALTY WLU personal foul 15 yards to the SHEP33, 1ST DOWN WLU. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep33 | Tyler Tucci rush for loss of 30 yards to the WLU37 (Tommy Hawks). |
| Wlu | 2-40 | at Wlu37 | 2nd and 6. |
| Wlu | 2-6 | at Wlu37 | Zach Amedro rush for 35 yards to the SHEP28, 1ST DOWN WLU (Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep28 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 2 yards to the SHEP26 (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 2-8 | at Shep26 | Zach Amedro sacked for loss of 7 yards to the SHEP33 (Bryan Letournea). |
| Wlu | 3-15 | at Shep33 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 05:49. |
| Wlu | 3-15 | at Shep33 | Change of possession, SHEP ball on SHEP33, 1st and 10. |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 47 yards, TOP 02:32 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep33 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Dom Jones for 14 yards to the SHEP47, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Law. Robinson). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep47 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Neal Hardie for 22 yards to the WLU31, 1ST DOWN SHEP, out-of-bounds (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu31 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Larry Lowe for 12 yards to the WLU19, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Fred Kimbro). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu19 | Kevin Clancy rush for 7 yards to the WLU12. |
| Shep | 2-3 | at Wlu12 | Tommy Addison rush for 2 yards to the WLU10 (Alec Wood). |
| Shep | 3-1 | at Wlu10 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Dom Jones. |
| Shep | 4-1 | at Wlu10 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Robert Byrd, PENALTY SHEP pass interference declined. |
| | | Drive: 7 plays, 57 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu10 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 03:17. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu10 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 8 yards to the WLU18 (Cor. Washington). |
| Wlu | 2-2 | at Wlu18 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Willie Walker. |
| Wlu | 3-2 | at Wlu18 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 7 yards to the WLU25, 1ST DOWN WLU (Maurice Perry), PENALTY SHEP offside declined. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu25 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 40 yards to the SHEP35 (Maurice Perry), PENALTY WLU holding (Ryan Scaperotta) 10 yards to the WLU15, NO PLAY. |
| Wlu | 1-20 | at Wlu15 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 6 yards to the WLU21 (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 2-14 | at Wlu21 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Ryan Travis. |
| Wlu | 3-14 | at Wlu21 | PENALTY WLU false start (DeVaughn Gordon) 5 yards to the WLU16. |
| Wlu | 3-19 | at Wlu16 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Kevon Calhoun. |
| Wlu | 4-19 | at Wlu16 | Mike Blewett punt 36 yards to the SHEP48, Deante Steele return 52 yards to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:52. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 6 yards, TOP 02:25 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | West Liberty U 35, Shepherd 27 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 70 yards to the WLU0, touchback. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 00:50. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu20 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 14 yards to the WLU34, 1ST DOWN WLU, out-of-bounds (Chris Patton). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu34 | PENALTY SHEP personal foul (Chris Patton) 15 yards to the WLU49, 1ST DOWN WLU. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu49 | Zach Amedro pass intercepted by Keon Robinson at the SHEP12, Keon Robinson return 88 yards to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:03. |
| | | Drive: 2 plays, 29 yards, TOP 00:47 |
| | | Kevin Clancy pass attempt to Bobby Humphries good. |
| | | Shepherd 35, West Liberty U 35 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 68 yards to the WLU2, DeVaughn Gordon return 22 yards to the WLU24 (Jordan Tucker), PENALTY WLU illegal block 14 yards to the WLU10, 1st and 10, WLU ball on WLU10. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu10 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 00:00. |
| | | Shepherd 35, West Liberty U 35 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu10 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu10 | DeVaughn Gordon rush for 4 yards to the WLU14, fumble by DeVaughn Gordon recovered by SHEP TEAM at WLU14. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 4 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu14 | SHEPHERD drive start at 15:00. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu14 | Tommy Addison rush for 2 yards to the WLU12 (Mike Buffo). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Wlu12 | Tommy Addison rush for 2 yards to the WLU10 (Raphael Johnson). |
| Shep | 3-6 | at Wlu10 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Larry Lowe for 3 yards to the WLU7 (Clay Beeler). |
| Shep | 4-3 | at Wlu07 | Eric Dobratz field goal attempt from 24 GOOD, clock 13:02. |
| | | Shepherd 38, West Liberty U 35 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 7 yards, TOP 02:04 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 63 yards to the WLU7, Justin Brewton return 16 yards to the WLU23 (Adam Ritchey). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu23 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 12:56. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu23 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Brandon Carver for 4 yards to the WLU27, fumble forced by Brian Taylor, fumble by Brandon Carver recovered by SHEP Cor. Washington at WLU27, Cor. Washington for 27 yards to the WLU0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 12:45. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 4 yards, TOP 00:11 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kick attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd 45, West Liberty U 35 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 58 yards to the WLU12, Marcus George return 14 yards to the WLU26 (Deon Jones). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu26 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 12:41. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu26 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 9 yards to the WLU35 (Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 2-1 | at Wlu35 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 10 yards to the WLU45, Ryan Travis for 6 yards to the SHEP49, 1ST DOWN WLU. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep49 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 21 yards to the SHEP28, fumble forced by Keon Robinson, fumble by Willie Walker recovered by WLU TEAM at SHEP27, 1ST DOWN WLU. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep27 | WLU ball on SHEP27. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep27 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 14 yards to the SHEP13, 1ST DOWN WLU (Cor. Washington). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep13 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Brandon Carver. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep13 | 2nd and 10. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep13 | Kevon Calhoun rush for 7 yards to the SHEP6 (Mike Franklin). |
| Wlu | 3-3 | at Shep06 | Zach Amedro sacked for loss of 4 yards to the SHEP10 (Bryan Letournea). |
| Wlu | 4-7 | at Shep10 | Mike Blewett field goal attempt from 27 GOOD, clock 09:36. |
| | | Shepherd 45, West Liberty U 38 |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 64 yards, TOP 03:10 |
| | | Jeff Hoak kickoff 24 yards to the SHEP46, Bobby Humphries return 9 yards to the WLU45 (Andre Robinson). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu45 | SHEPHERD drive start at 09:31. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Wlu45 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Jimmy Sutch for 19 yards to the WLU26 (Alec Wood), PENALTY SHEP holding (Geoff Fry) 10 yards to the SHEP45, NO PLAY. |
| Shep | 1-20 | at Shep45 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Tommy Addison for 14 yards to the WLU41 (Nick Ringwalt). |
| Shep | 2-6 | at Wlu41 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Nik Norrell. |
| Shep | 3-6 | at Wlu41 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Jimmy Sutch. |
| Shep | 4-6 | at Wlu41 | Eric Dobratz punt 32 yards to the WLU9, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 4 yards, TOP 01:21 |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu09 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 08:10. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu09 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 8 yards to the WLU17 (A.J. Parrish). |
| Wlu | 2-2 | at Wlu17 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 2 yards to the WLU19, 1ST DOWN WLU (Mike Franklin). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu19 | Kevon Calhoun rush for no gain to the WLU19 (Brian Taylor). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu19 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Willie Walker for 6 yards to the WLU25 (Maurice Perry). |
| Wlu | 3-4 | at Wlu25 | Zach Amedro rush for 8 yards to the WLU33, 1ST DOWN WLU, out-of-bounds. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu33 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Ryan Travis. |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Wlu33 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Kevon Calhoun for 3 yards to the WLU36 (Chris Patton). |
| Wlu | 3-7 | at Wlu36 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Jermaine Carter (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 4-7 | at Wlu36 | Mike Blewett punt 34 yards to the SHEP30, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 27 yards, TOP 03:33 |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep30 | SHEPHERD drive start at 04:37. |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep30 | Tommy Addison rush for no gain to the SHEP30 (Mike Buffo). |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep30 | Timeout West Liberty U, clock 04:32. |
| Shep | 2-10 | at Shep30 | Kevin Clancy pass incomplete to Robert Byrd. |
| Shep | 3-10 | at Shep30 | Kevin Clancy pass complete to Jimmy Sutch for 10 yards to the SHEP40, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Mike Buffo). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep40 | Tommy Addison rush for 9 yards to the SHEP49 (Carl Hayles). |
| Shep | 2-1 | at Shep49 | Tommy Addison rush for loss of 1 yard to the SHEP48 (Matt Betz). |
| Shep | 3-2 | at Shep48 | Timeout West Liberty U, clock 03:04. |
| Shep | 3-2 | at Shep48 | Bobby Humphries rush for 2 yards to the 50 yardline, 1ST DOWN SHEP (Matt Betz). |
| Shep | 1-10 | at Shep50 | Tommy Addison rush for 2 yards to the WLU48 (Clay Beeler). |
| Shep | 2-8 | at Wlu48 | Tommy Addison rush for 4 yards to the WLU44 (Law. Robinson). |
| Shep | 3-4 | at Wlu44 | Tommy Addison rush for 44 yards to the WLU0, 1ST DOWN SHEP, TOUCHDOWN, clock 00:46. |
| | | John Frick rush attempt good. |
| | | Shepherd 53, West Liberty U 38 |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 70 yards, TOP 03:56 |
| | | Eric Dobratz kickoff 56 yards to the WLU14, Marcus George return 18 yards to the WLU32 (Kain Metz). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu32 | WEST LIBERTY U drive start at 00:41. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu32 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 13 yards to the WLU45, 1ST DOWN WLU, out-of-bounds. |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Wlu45 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Pauly Ferguson for 10 yards to the SHEP45, 1ST DOWN WLU (Cor. Washington). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep45 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Ryan Travis for 7 yards to the SHEP38, out-of-bounds (Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 2-3 | at Shep38 | Zach Amedro sacked for loss of 5 yards to the SHEP43 (Xavier Tyler). |
| Wlu | 3-8 | at Shep43 | Timeout West Liberty U, clock 00:07. |
| Wlu | 3-8 | at Shep43 | 2nd and 14. |
| Wlu | 2-14 | at Shep43 | Zach Amedro pass complete to Jermaine Carter for 18 yards to the SHEP25, 1ST DOWN WLU (Elijah Davis). |
| Wlu | 1-10 | at Shep25 | Zach Amedro pass incomplete to Pauly Ferguson (Keon Robinson). |
| Wlu | 2-10 | at Shep25 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 43 yards, TOP 00:41 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Shepherd 53, West Liberty U 38 |